By Kent Mensah
Posted on Thursday, 10 March 2022 16:31
A 30-year-old rule in Ghana’s parliament has been deemed unconstitutional, thereby giving space to Deputy Speakers to vote on key decisions, particularly the government’s proposed tax on electronic transactions that has divided the house for months.
The government’s bid to pass a new levy to raise enough domestic revenue to save a distressed economy received a major boost following a landmark Supreme Court judgement on Wednesday 9 March.
Parliament has been split down the middle on the question of the proposed levy between the two main political parties – 137 seats each for the two main political parties – with an independent candidate associating with the governing New Patriotic Party (NPP), thereby giving them a slim majority.
This poses a risk of major gridlock on finalising national business, especially when it comes to passing bills in the absence of the substantive Speaker. In situations like this, a Deputy Speaker, who is required by law to be an MP, presides automatically dropping the vote on the governing party’s side.
READ MORE Ghana: Six things to know about Alban Bagbin, the controversial speaker of Parliament
But since late December, a situation arose after Deputy Speaker Joseph Osei-Owusu attempted to count himself as forming a quorum for a vote on the budget. According to the rules of Ghana’s Parliament: “A Deputy Speaker or any other member presiding shall not retain his original vote while presiding”.
The court’s decision on Wednesday will ease that gridlock, after it unanimously that a Deputy Speaker presiding over proceedings in Parliament is still an MP and can vote and be counted as part of the quorum for decision-making in the House.
“Order 109 (3) of the Standing Orders of Parliament, which state that ‘a Deputy Speaker or any other member presiding shall not retain his original vote while presiding’, is unconstitutional and same is struck out as unconstitutional,” the court said of the 30-year-old constitutional provision.
The Electronic Transaction Levy (E-Levy) is looking to raise over GHC6.9bn (€800m) annually for the national coffers. The bill has been in limbo since November 2021 because the governing New Patriotic Party (NPP) cannot form a quorum for a vote on the bill.
This clearly is a travesty of Parliamentary justice to pave way for the passage of Akufo-Addo’s E-Levy. This won’t happen elsewhere in the world.
The levy, if passed by parliament, will essentially increase taxes on mobile money transfers, which are used by 40% of Ghanaian, aged 15 years and above, according to a 2021 data by the Bank of Ghana.
READ MORE Ghana: Weak economy, high cost of living will drive more strikes warn experts
Having vehemently opposed the controversial E-Levy, saying it will add to the hardship of Ghanaians, the minority in Parliament claim the Supreme Court’s ruling was biased.
“This clearly is a travesty of Parliamentary justice to pave way for the passage of Akufo-Addo’s E-Levy. This won’t happen elsewhere in the world. We respect the decision of the Supreme Court, but this particular ruling is so disappointing and repugnant. The decision amounts to judicial interference in Parliamentary practice,” the minority Leader Haruna Iddrisu tells The Africa Report.
READ MORE Ghana pushes national cathedral project despite economic wobbles
Former President John Mahama also described the ruling as shocking in a Facebook post.
“A unanimous 7-0? Shocking but not surprising. An unfortunate interpretation for convenience that sets a dangerous precedent of judicial interference in Parliamentary procedure for the future,” the post said.
For his part, Attorney General Godfred Yeboah Dame hailed the ruling.
“The law is clear and devoid of any controversy. In other jurisdictions like the UK and America Deputy Speakers of Parliament are MPs and always have the right to vote. Even in Kenya and South Africa here in Africa the rules are the same,” Dame tells The Africa Report.
READ MORE Ghana’s debt makes development impossible: Here are some solutions
“The Minority’s argument, in effect, is saying that when the Deputy Speaker is presiding, he loses the right to represent his people in Parliament and therefore cannot vote on issues. That’s wrong. The ruling of the Supreme Court is sound,” he adds.
Speaking to the press afterwards, the First Deputy Speaker Osei-Owusu said the ruling of the apex court vindicates him.
“Indeed, this decision (Supreme Court ruling) affirms that position that I took. I find that very refreshing. Matters that have never arisen are now in the fore because of the numbers we have in the chambers so anytime there’s disagreement, as I’ve said already, I’ll interpret the rule and the law as I understand it. I encourage people who disagree with me to boldly state their position and if need be, refer it to the appropriate body like the Supreme Court to guide us,” he said.
The executive director of the Parliamentary Network Africa, Sammy Obeng, said there is no winner or loser in the case, urging both parties to leverage on the decision to strengthen Ghana’s Parliamentary democracy.
READ MORE Ghana: Card registration problems persist as citizens fear lack of access to services
“It’s only appropriate that the parties involved get to respect the decision of the Supreme Court. I’m particularly surprised about it, especially quashing a law that has been with us for all these decades, but we’ll wait for the full decision.
“In any case, we need to protect our Parliamentary democracy. We got to abide by the rules. I don’t think anyone has won or lost. Let’s just leverage on it and move on,” says Obeng.
Understand Africa’s tomorrow… today
We believe that Africa is poorly represented, and badly under-estimated. Beyond the vast opportunity manifest in African markets, we highlight people who make a difference; leaders turning the tide, youth driving change, and an indefatigable business community. That is what we believe will change the continent, and that is what we report on. With hard-hitting investigations, innovative analysis and deep dives into countries and sectors, The Africa Report delivers the insight you need.
Give yourself a headstart:
Get full access to The Africa Report on all your devices.
Talks to bring an end to Africa’s deadliest conflict are continuing in South Africa, two days after they were due to conclude. …
Ghana takes over leadership of the UN Security Council today (1 November) with the stated goal of rethinking international peacekeeping in … Africa.
The world’s largest heated pipeline will produce 216,000 barrels of crude oil per day as it covers 1,443km from Uganda to Tanzania. Its climate … and humanitarian impact have been criticised by NGOs and the European Union while its leading investor, the French oil company TotalEnergies, and local governments defend its development and employment opportunities.
The relationship between Rwanda and DRC has hit a new low after Kinshasa expelled the Rwandan ambassador Saturday night. The expulsion comes … amidst a resurgence of fighting in North Kivu, in eastern DRC between M23 rebels and the ‘Forces armées de la république démocratique du Congo’ (FARDC) resulting in the former gaining more territory. But getting to this point has included miscalculations in the part of DRC. The expulsion is the harshest decision that Kinshasa has taken.
Your browser could not fetch this story