ADVERTISEMENT
  • Contact Us
  • security
  • About Us
  • social
  • Celebrity
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Developer
  • Livescore
Thursday, March 23, 2023
FacetvNews
  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • world news
  • Online Radio
  • Ghana News
  • Africa News
  • Music
  • Videos
  • Entertainment
  • Religion
  • Fixtures & Standings
  • Livescore
  • Home
  • world news
  • Online Radio
  • Ghana News
  • Africa News
  • Music
  • Videos
  • Entertainment
  • Religion
  • Fixtures & Standings
  • Livescore
No Result
View All Result
Morning News
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Education

Bright Simons: Digital taxes in Africa flop but Ghana wants in

Facetvnews by Facetvnews
December 7, 2021
in Education
0
Educate youth activists to follow laid down procedures – Political parties urged
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
ADVERTISEMENT

This is a short postscript to my earlier note on Ghana’s proposed e-Levy. In view of certain reactions to that piece, I felt that a quick span of the experiences of other countries that have gone this route, which I had suggested offhandedly in my note, would actually illuminate some of the points rather well. So here goes.

There are, near as I can tell, seven countries in Africa that have imposed or set in motion plans to impose mobile money taxes:

READ ALSO

The great tall African man Yasuke from a mighty but unknown Land

Minister directs GES to vary Chiana SHS girls’ dismissal after President’s intervention

  1. Kenya imposes a 12% excise tax on transaction fees a while back. Whilst such excise taxes end up being passed on to consumers, and therefore can be retrogressive, the net absolute effect might still be smaller as when competition succeeds in bringing down fees the tax effects will reduce automatically. Moreover, after all, they apply to income earned and not just movement of funds. Uganda attempted to impose a 2% fee on transaction value but retreated after a massive public backlash to 0.5%.
  2. Malawi imposed a 1% fee on transaction value and has since retreated.
  3. Tanzania wanted to introduce a graduated levy of between 0.43 cents and 4.35 USD depending on the amount being sent. The President has asked that this be reviewed downwards. Reduction in transaction volumes and value have already greeted the policy announcement. 
  4. Zimbabwe has a 2% fee on transaction value.
  5. The remaining countries – Cote D’Ivoire, Congo Brazzaville and DRC – apply the tax on the mobile operator’s turnover.

None of these countries make significant revenue from e-Money related taxes, yet there is considerable evidence of significant distortions of the digital economy since the imposition of these taxes.

  • Kenya makes less than $100m a year.
  • Uganda is around $27m a year (total transaction volume has fallen by about 27% in recent times).
  • In Zimbabwe, the 2% intermediated mobile tax is on course to yield about $50 million by the end of this year.

Ghana’s projected $1.15 billion return is, as should be clear from the foregoing, completely out of line with experiences elsewhere and a sign of weak policy formulation and prior research.

If actual outturn follows the experience of the country’s Communications Service Tax (CST, aka “Talk Tax”), where wildly optimistic expectations failed to pan out, we may end up with something in the region of say, $150m, and yet would be paying $40m to prevent vaguely defined “evasion”. The $40 million set aside for collection of the e-Levy is aggravating general discomfort about the whole enterprise. Given that the budget was expected to pass around next week and implementation of the tax meant to start on 1st January 2022, it is hard to believe the Government when it says that an open, competitive and transparent procurement process had been planned. How long does it take to even write up the Terms of Reference for a serious Expression of Interest (EOI) process?

All this makes one worry that the planned $40 million e-Levy administration service could end up as badly for the country in ratio terms as the CST revenue monitoring situation involving Subah, Kelni GVG and Afriwave. At one point, the country was spending $32 million in various electronic revenue protection measures, none of which made technical sense, yet total CST take was still hovering in the region of $54 million (2017). That is to say, Ghana was spending more than half of the money it was collecting on policing the same money. 

Historical experience, like cross-country comparative experience, counsel serious caution and widespread consultation about how the country goes about designing and implementing any digital tax measures. 

If these measures are motivated purely by problem-solving, rather than by procurement opportunities, then why is extensive stakeholder consultation always so hard?


SOURCE: Nii Otu Dadeban Ankrah

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related Posts

The great tall African man Yasuke from a mighty but unknown Land

The great tall African man Yasuke from a mighty but unknown Land

January 16, 2023
6
Education

Minister directs GES to vary Chiana SHS girls’ dismissal after President’s intervention

January 14, 2023 - Updated on January 15, 2023
1
children of israel debate
Education

”Who Are The Real Children Of Israel?”

January 10, 2023
0
36 bodies were found in unmarked colonial graves
History

36 bodies were found in unmarked colonial graves. DNA is revealing their stories.

Meet Beebu a talented Nigerian popular Yoruba musician 

Meet Beebu a talented Nigerian popular Yoruba musician 

January 5, 2023 - Updated on January 9, 2023
71
Shocking meaning and symbols of baby born with dreadlocks (Dada).

Shocking meaning and symbols of baby born with dreadlocks (Dada).

December 19, 2022
32
Next Post

Martin Amidu: The shameless compromises of the one-party political elite against the Ghanaian electorate – 2022 Budget

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

POPULAR NEWS

Meet the great chef from Zimbabwe who has been around the world

Meet the great chef from Zimbabwe who has been around the world

December 12, 2022 - Updated on December 13, 2022
252
The young Ghanaian woman who became CEO at a tender age.

The young Ghanaian woman who became CEO at a tender age.

December 15, 2022
202
Meet the young vibrant Ghanaian dancehall artiste making waves in Accra Ghana.

Meet the young vibrant Ghanaian dancehall artiste making waves in Accra Ghana.

January 5, 2023 - Updated on January 9, 2023
94
Meet Beebu a talented Nigerian popular Yoruba musician 

Meet Beebu a talented Nigerian popular Yoruba musician 

January 5, 2023 - Updated on January 9, 2023
71
support our own – Black Sheriff

support our own – Black Sheriff

December 5, 2022 - Updated on December 6, 2022
36
ADVERTISEMENT

EDITOR'S PICK

Universal Motors Limited wins big at Ghana Auto Awards – Graphic Online

November 1, 2022
0
Illinois high school football playoffs: Check IHSA brackets, get live score updates – Scorebook Live

Illinois high school football playoffs: Check IHSA brackets, get live score updates – Scorebook Live

November 6, 2022
0

Andrej Kramaric interview: Leaving Leicester City to become a Bundesliga sensation and a Hoffenheim legend – Sky Sports

November 9, 2022
0

Top 10 Entertainment News Of The Week: Sara-Shubman's viral pic; Hrithik Roshan's 3 looks in 'Vikram Vedha' – mid-day.com

October 27, 2022
0

About

Facetvnews

News $ Entertainment

We bring you the best new and entertainment, etc. Check our landing page for details. Download the app

Follow us

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Davido set to release his “Timeless” album on March 31
  • Shatta Wale gives conditions for VGMA return
  • Divorce: Causes and Effects on Children
  • Agnosticism and Gnostism
  • Manage Blood Sugar
  • Fixtures & Standings
  • Livescore
  • Contact Developer
  • Contact Us
  • Online Radio

© 2022 FactvNews -all rights reserved | Powered by Mcperry Imaginations.

No Result
View All Result
  • Homepages
    • Home Page 1
  • Politics
  • National
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • Science

© 2022 FactvNews -all rights reserved | Powered by Mcperry Imaginations.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Sign Up with Facebook
Sign Up with Google
Sign Up with Linked In
OR

Fill the forms below to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
%d bloggers like this: